Creating the United States

{ object_type: 'Exhibit Item',embed_type: 'image',embed_detail: 'http://www.myloc.gov/_assets/Exhibitions/creatingtheus/BillofRights/DemandforaBillofRights/Assets/us0078_01tiff_enlarge_125.Jpeg',embed_alt: 'A “whipsyllabub” or “a tub thrown out to a whale”',thumbnail: {url: 'http://www.myloc.gov/_assets/Exhibitions/creatingtheus/BillofRights/DemandforaBillofRights/Assets/us0078_01tiff_enlarge_125.Jpeg',alt: 'A “whipsyllabub” or “a tub thrown out to a whale”',height: '66',width: '125'} }

A “whipsyllabub” or “a tub thrown out to a whale”

A “whipsyllabub” or “a tub thrown out to a whale”

See Silverlight version of this item » About this item        

Many supporters and opponents of the proposed amendments to the federal Constitution known as the “Bill of Rights” considered them a diversion from substantive changes to the Constitution. Aedanus Burke (1743–1802), an anti-federalist Congressman from South Carolina, asserted on August 15, 1789 that they were “little better than whipsyllabub, frothy and full of wind” and were like “a tub thrown out to a whale, to secure the freight of the ship and its peaceable voyage.”
Many supporters and opponents of the proposed amendments to the federal Constitution known as the “Bill of Rights” considered them a diversion from substantive changes to the Constitution. Aedanus Burke (1743–1802), an anti-federalist Congressman from South Carolina, asserted on August 15, 1789 that they were “little better than whipsyllabub, frothy and full of wind” and were like “a tub thrown out to a whale, to secure the freight of the ship and its peaceable voyage.”